Is MyBuilder Worth It for Tradesmen? UK Guide
Short answer
MyBuilder can be worth it once you work out what a job is worth to you and your breakeven cost per shortlist, but it is a gamble if you pay without knowing that number first.
Is MyBuilder worth it for tradesmen? It can pay for itself if you work out what a job is worth to you before you pay for a single shortlist, but it stops being worth it the moment you pay without knowing that number.
A lot of what's written about MyBuilder treats it as a straight marketing cost question: how much is a lead, how many do you need. That misses the things that matter just as much once you're actually trading: VAT on the fee, your duty to tell HMRC what you earn, and what happens to the reviews you've built up if you ever stop paying.
Work out your breakeven number before you pay for a shortlist
Before you touch MyBuilder, work out what a job is worth to you. Follow these steps:
- Work out your average profit on a job in your trade, not the total price: materials and labour come off first.
- Think about how many shortlists you normally need before you land one job like that, being honest rather than hopeful.
- Divide your profit by that number. That is the most a single shortlist could cost before it stops paying for itself.
Say you fit kitchens at around £20,000 a job, and keep roughly £6,000 of that as profit once materials and labour are paid. If it takes about three shortlists on average to land one job like that, divide £6,000 by three: that is £2,000, the most a shortlist could in theory cost before this particular job stops paying for itself. Check that figure against whatever MyBuilder actually charges for a shortlist in your trade, on their current pricing page.
How much does MyBuilder charge per lead?
MyBuilder works on a pay-per-shortlist model rather than a flat monthly membership: you only pay once you're shown to a homeowner as one of a short list of tradesmen for their job. The fee changes by trade and by job, so check their current pricing page before you build it into a budget rather than relying on a number you've seen quoted elsewhere.
The useful habit is to track every shortlist you pay for against whether it turns into a quote, and whether that quote turns into a job. Keep a simple note, paper or a spreadsheet, so you can run the breakeven sum above with your own real numbers once you've got a run of shortlists behind you.
Not every shortlist turns into a genuine customer ready to hire: some homeowners are still pricing the job up and checking a budget rather than ready to book anyone. A quick phone call before you write a full quote, asking about timing and budget, filters those out fast and saves you writing a proper quote for someone who isn't ready.
Do you pay VAT on top of the shortlist fee?
This depends on whether you're VAT registered, not on anything MyBuilder decides for you. UK businesses must register for VAT once their taxable turnover goes above £90,000, and can register voluntarily below that figure if they choose to (GOV.UK).
If you're VAT registered, expect VAT to be added on top of whatever fee MyBuilder states, the same as any other business cost you buy. If you're not registered, that extra charge doesn't apply to you, so the price you see is the price you pay. Ask your accountant which applies to you if you're not sure.
Declare what you earn to HMRC
A job you win through MyBuilder is income like any other job you win, and HMRC treats it that way. A sole trader must register for Self Assessment once they earn more than £1,000 in a tax year from working for themselves (GOV.UK).
Keep a simple log of which jobs came from MyBuilder, what you paid in shortlist fees, and what the job was worth. That log makes your tax return easier and gives you the real numbers for the breakeven sum. Check with your accountant on exactly how to record it.
Know where you stand if a job goes wrong
MyBuilder finding you the job changes nothing about your legal position once you're on site. Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 every trader must carry out the work with reasonable care and skill, and if you agree a refund because something's wrong, the law says you should pay it within 14 days rather than whenever suits you (Citizens Advice).
Put this in writing before you start, not after there's a row: what you'll do if the homeowner isn't happy, and how you'll agree the job is finished. A line in your quote covering this saves a much longer argument later. Carrying your own public liability insurance matters whichever platform sends you the work, since MyBuilder listing you doesn't replace it.
Is MyBuilder better than Checkatrade for a small builder?
Neither is simply better: they charge differently, so the answer comes down to your own numbers again. MyBuilder charges per shortlist with no membership fee, while Checkatrade runs more on an ongoing membership model, which we've broken down separately in how much Checkatrade actually costs.
If you win work steadily and want a flatter, more predictable cost, membership-style pricing can suit you better. If your work is lumpy, busy some months and quiet others, paying per shortlist only when you want more work can suit a small firm better.
Bark works differently again, more like a marketplace where you buy credits to contact a lead, so comparing the three properly means working out your own breakeven number on each one rather than going by reputation alone.
Whichever platform you use, nobody wins a job by sending a quote and hoping. Reply fast, chase every quote you send, and run the numbers above every few months as your prices and margins move, as we've covered in how to chase a quote without being pushy. Get the breakeven sum right and MyBuilder is just another number on a page, not a gamble.
Questions people ask
Is MyBuilder free to join for tradesmen?
Signing up is normally free, and you only start paying once you choose to send a quote and get shown to a homeowner as a shortlisted tradesman. Check MyBuilder's current pricing page for what counts as a paid shortlist in your trade.
Can I get a refund if a MyBuilder lead goes cold?
MyBuilder's own terms decide this, not any general rule, so read their current cancellation and refund policy before you rely on a shortlist going anywhere.
How many shortlists does it take to win one job on MyBuilder?
There's no fixed figure: work out your own conversion rate from the quotes you've actually sent in the past, and use that to judge whether the shortlists are earning their keep, as covered in the breakeven section above.
Can I cancel my MyBuilder account at any time?
Check their current terms for exactly how cancellation works since this can change, but in general you stop future shortlists while your existing profile may stay visible.
Do my MyBuilder reviews count if I move to my own website?
The reviews stay on your MyBuilder profile rather than moving with you, so copy the text of your best ones across to your own site and your Google Business Profile while you still have access.
Are the leads on MyBuilder genuine or fake?
Genuine homeowners post the jobs, but not everyone posting is ready to hire straight away, so treat every shortlist as worth a quick qualifying call before you spend time on a full quote.
Why haven't you replied yet?
Homeowners ask this when you've gone quiet. Usually it means you were on the tools and missed the call. Imagine two extra bespoke kitchens a month at £45,000 each: that's £90,000 on the diary if you're first to reply. Book a free twenty-minute call with Ben or Sam and we'll look at how you win work now.
Prefer to talk now? Call Sam: 07407 610646
Month to month · No contract · You own every account